Italy anger understandable after bar manager release, says Swiss president
Milan – Italian anger over the release on bail of the bar manager linked to a deadly New Year’s Day fire in Switzerland is understandable, Swiss President Guy Parmelin has said, while stressing that judicial authorities operate independently from political influence.
The comments come amid rising diplomatic tension between Italy and Switzerland following the tragedy that killed dozens and left many injured.
The fire broke out in the early hours of January 1 at a crowded bar in the Swiss ski resort of Crans Montana.
The incident claimed 40 lives, including six Italian nationals, and injured more than 100 people, sending shockwaves through both countries.
The release on bail of the bar owner, Jacques Moretti, sparked widespread outrage in Italy. Families of victims, political leaders, and media outlets criticised the decision, calling it insensitive and deeply distressing.
Italy’s prime minister described the move as a serious affront to grieving families and those still recovering in hospital. Officials argued that releasing the suspect undermined trust in the judicial process and delayed accountability for the tragedy.
In an interview with an Italian newspaper, Swiss President Parmelin acknowledged the emotional reaction in Italy. He said the indignation was understandable given the scale of the loss and the number of Italian victims involved.
At the same time, Parmelin emphasised that Switzerland’s legal system is independent. He noted that politicians cannot and should not interfere in judicial decisions taken by magistrates.
The diplomatic situation escalated when Italy recalled its ambassador from Switzerland for consultations. Italian authorities said the move was intended to formally convey their dissatisfaction to Swiss prosecutors.
Rome has also called for the creation of a joint Italian Swiss investigative team. Italian leaders believe closer cooperation would help ensure transparency and fairness in the investigation.
Parmelin said Switzerland had not been officially informed in advance of the ambassador’s recall. He described the move as a routine diplomatic measure rather than a hostile act.
According to the Swiss president, such recalls are part of normal diplomatic dialogue. He added that after consultations, ambassadors typically return to their posts without long term consequences.
The tragedy has had a profound impact on public opinion in Italy. Media coverage has been intense, with daily updates focusing on victims, survivors, and unanswered questions.
Families of those who died have demanded justice and accountability. Many have questioned safety standards, crowd control, and emergency preparedness at the venue.
Swiss authorities have said investigations are ongoing. Prosecutors are examining possible violations of safety regulations and responsibility for the fire.
The incident has also prompted wider discussions in both countries. Officials and experts are debating fire safety laws, inspection procedures, and enforcement in nightlife venues.
Despite the diplomatic strain, both sides have signalled a desire to maintain constructive relations. Swiss leaders have expressed sympathy for the victims and pledged full cooperation within legal boundaries.
Italian officials continue to push for stronger involvement in the investigation. They argue that the presence of Italian victims justifies closer bilateral coordination.
As legal proceedings continue, emotions remain high. The case is likely to remain a sensitive issue in Italy Switzerland relations in the coming months.
The Swiss president’s remarks appear aimed at calming tensions while reaffirming respect for the rule of law. Whether this will ease Italian anger depends largely on the outcome and transparency of the investigation.
